Dropping stem's PathSupport project from the page
Damian Johnson

Damian Johnson commited on 2013-03-08 18:00:50
Zeige 1 geänderte Dateien mit 0 Einfügungen und 62 Löschungen.


Last year I proposed a stem counterpart for PathSupport as a project for GSoC.
This did not go very well since we really haven't a clue *what* we want from
such a project. Since then this has not changed and there's little reason to
leave it on the page (even commented out).


... ...
@@ -1650,68 +1650,6 @@ meetings around the world.</li>
1650 1650
     </li>
1651 1651
     -->
1652 1652
 
1653
-    <!--
1654
-    <a id="stemPathsupport"></a>
1655
-    <li>
1656
-    <b>Stem PathSupport Capabilities</b>
1657
-    <br>
1658
-    Effort Level: <i>High</i>
1659
-    <br>
1660
-    Skill Level: <i>Medium</i>
1661
-    <br>
1662
-    Likely Mentors: <i>Damian (atagar)</i>
1663
-    <p><a
1664
-    href="https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/stem">Stem</a> is a
1665
-    python controller library for tor. Like it's predecessor, <a
1666
-    href="#project-torctl">TorCtl</a>, it uses tor's <a
1667
-    href="https://gitweb.torproject.org/torspec.git/blob/HEAD:/control-spec.txt">control
1668
-    protocol</a> to help developers program against the tor process, enabling
1669
-    them to build things similar to <a href="#project-vidalia">Vidalia</a> and
1670
-    <a href="#project-arm">arm</a>.</p>
1671
-
1672
-    <p>While TorCtl provided a fine first draft for this sort of functionality,
1673
-    it has not proved to be extensible nor maintainable. Stem is a rewrite of
1674
-    TorCtl with a heavy focus on testing, documentation, and providing a
1675
-    developer friendly API.</p>
1676
-
1677
-    <p>At the moment stem is still very much incomplete, missing several pieces
1678
-    of functionality that TorCtl provides. This is a project to fix that by
1679
-    porting TorCtl's <a
1680
-    href="https://gitweb.torproject.org/pytorctl.git/blob/HEAD:/PathSupport.py">PathSupport
1681
-    module</a> to stem, writing tests for it, and migrate a couple clients to
1682
-    use it.</p>
1683
-
1684
-    <p>PathSupport provides applications with programmatic control over how
1685
-    tor's circuits are built, for instance letting you exit from particular
1686
-    relays. This is used by projects like <a href="#project-torbel">TorBEL</a>,
1687
-    <a href="#project-torflow">the Bandwidth Scanners, and SoaT</a>.</p>
1688
-
1689
-    <p>This project can be broken into three parts...</p>
1690
-
1691
-    <ol style="list-style-type: decimal">
1692
-      <li><p>Look at PathSupport's clients to figure out how it is used and
1693
-      come up with the API that we will use for stem. Note that the goal if
1694
-      this project is <b>not</b> to simply copy PathSupport, but to make it
1695
-      better. This task would ideally be done as part of writing the GSoC
1696
-      application.</p></li>
1697
-      <li><p>Implement the PathSupport counterpart for stem. This should be
1698
-      done in an incremental fashion, writing the feature, tests, and going
1699
-      through a code review before moving on. I'll be pretty anal about making
1700
-      it as good as we can during these code reviews so plan for this to take a
1701
-      while. ;)</p></li>
1702
-      <li><p>The real test of the API that you've developed will come when we
1703
-      use it in some real applications. Try to migrate a TorCtl client or two
1704
-      to stem, filling in functionality that we're missing and improving our
1705
-      API as we discover issues. A particularly good client to start with would
1706
-      be TorBEL.</p></li>
1707
-    </ol>
1708
-
1709
-    <p><b>
1710
-    Upon reflection this is not an especially good project for this year's GSoC. You are still perfectly wecome to apply for this project, but <a href="https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/stem">other stem related tasks</a> such as implementing a general controller, descriptor fetching, and client migrations would be better. For the discussion that lead to this see <a href="http://archives.seul.org/or/dev/Apr-2012/msg00006.html">this thread</a>.
1711
-    </b></p>
1712
-    </li>
1713
-    -->
1714
-
1715 1653
     <a id="stemUsability"></a>
1716 1654
     <li>
1717 1655
     <b>Stem Usability and Porting</b>
1718 1656